The Wisdom in Geoff Dyer’s Crankiness

I had never read anything by Geoff Dyer until I picked up Out of Sheer Rage, in which he documents his experience of working on a biography of D. H. Lawrence and the various tangents his quest takes him on. Having finished it, I now want to read everything he’s written to date. There’s something addictive about seeing the world through the eyes of cynical, cranky old men. They don’t mince their words and often belt out wisdom in exactly the form I like it doled out – sarcastic and realistic.

A few years back, my ophthalmologist, after examining a benign accumulation of fluid in my retina, informed me that I was probably a Type A personality – one who lives diligently by the clock and is obsessed with getting things done. Dyer had a more elegant explanation of the mental state I sometimes find myself in:

I am always on the edge of what I am doing. I do everything badly, sloppily, to get it over with so that I can get on to the next thing that I will do badly and sloppily so that I can then do nothing – which I do anxiously, distractedly, wondering all the time if there isn’t something else I should be getting on with. ‘Being with you is like licking sugar through a glass,’ Laura once said. ‘You’re never quite there.’ When I’m working I’m wishing I was doing nothing and when I’m doing nothing I’m wondering if I should be working. I hurry through what I’ve got to do and then, when I’ve got nothing to do, I keep glancing at the clock, wishing it was time to go out. Then, when I’m out, I’m wondering how long it will be before I’m back home.

There are so many things I have zero interest in. Premier League football, Hindustani music, gardening, cooking, artisanal coffee and TGIF parties are just some of the pursuits that elicit zero excitement in me. While this has killed off many parallel worlds that I could have ‘lived’ in, I’ve never mourned my lack of engagement with them.

The important thing was the pleasure that came from not being interested in the theatre. I am interested in all sorts of things but it is lovely to not be interested in the theatre. Not being interested in the theatre means a whole area of life and culture means nothing to me: there are entire sections of listings magazines that I don’t need to consult, vast areas of conversation I don’t need to take part in, great wads of cash that I don’t need to consider parting with. It is bliss, not being interested in the theatre. Not being interested in the theatre provides me with more happiness than all the things I am interested in put together. There is a moral here. To be interested in something is to be involved in what is essentially a stressful relationship with that thing, to suffer anxiety on its behalf

When you travel to the hills or the beaches, the key ‘experience’ is supposed to be the stunning view from XYZ restaurant or a sunset for the ages. For Dyer this is the ‘hierarchical topography of tourism’.

To a fine restaurant with a magnificently deserted terrace overlooking the bay. Down below but still part of the same restaurant was another terrace, crowded, overlooking the bay. We had entered the hierarchical topography of tourism where everything, if it has any value, must be overlooking something else. Anything not overlooking something is to be looked down on. The lower terrace was less formal than the upper terrace – so formal, in fact, that there were no people in it – and so we walked down there. The waiter showed us to a table with a view overlooking the bay but Ciccio insisted on a better one, one with an even better view overlooking the bay

His existential take on Freedom was very Sartrean:

if we can throw in our job and head off, leave the safe life with a woman that we do not love and, as it were, come out – then we will be liberated, free. Moments – crises – like these are crucial to the cinema or theatre where psychological turmoil has to be externalised and compressed. Dramatically speaking what happens after moments such as these is unimportant even though the drama continues afterward, with the consequences of these sudden lurches beyond the quotidian. Up until then the question is what are you freeing yourself from; the real question, however, as Nietzsche points out – and Lawrence repeats in his Nietzschean Study of Thomas Hardy – is free for what? To be free is not the result of a moment’s decisive action but a project to be constantly renewed. More than anything else, freedom requires tenaciousness. There are intervals of repose but there will never come a state of definitive rest where you can give up because you have turned freedom into a permanent condition. Freedom is always precarious.

We’ve all had periods in our lives when we’ve tried to collect stuff. For me, at various points in my life, this has ranged from stamps and keychains to books, comics and fountain pens. Though some of these pursuits, in retrospect, seem empty, at the time, the very quest gave so much meaning to life. In Dyer’s words:

Should anyone flatter us by asking what we are looking for, what we are searching for, then we think immediately, almost instinctively, in vast terms – God, fulfilment, love – but our lives are actually made up of lots of tiny searches for things like a CD we are not sick of, an out-of-print edition of Phoenix, a picture of Lawrence that I saw when I was seventeen, another identical pair of suede shoes to the ones I am wearing now, even, I suppose, a cornetto integrale, ideally, a place where they serve perfect cornetti integrali each day without fail. Add them together and these little things make up an epic quest, more than enough for one lifetime.

Neither Hamnet nor Shakespeare in Love portrayed the Bard as a bald man. The young Shakespeare was certainly nothing like the image we have of him today. All writers and historical figures are frozen in our minds through stock images that accompany their works and that the media invariably reproduce whenever their names or works are evoked.

As authors continue to publish books the jacket photos are usually updated every few years: a given photograph corresponds to a given book, or a certain phase of work. In the case of dead authors one or two pictures come to stand for the entire life: all of Scott Fitzgerald’s books were written by the fresh-faced, unsozzled Scottie; all of Henry James’s by the bald magister. The longer the life, the greater the output, the more intense the degree of photographic compression: a single photograph of Dickens is sufficient to accommodate thirty years and tens of thousands of pages of work. Such a photograph serves to consolidate – to embody – the idea of the writer whose death was announced in a famous essay of Barthes. Or, to put it in terms consistent with his notion, a photograph of a writer is not really a photograph of a person but an emblem – a colophon – of the works published under his or her name. Inevitably a considerable degree of distortion takes place when a single photograph represents a working life covering several decades

On marital bliss (drumroll, please):

Laura’s version was ‘Together Forever’ mine was ‘Together Whenever’. Laura liked the idea of us sticking together ‘through thick and thin’ whereas I opted for the more pessimistic ‘through thin and thinner’.

I’m midway through his ‘Yoga for People Who Can’t Be Bothered to Do It‘ and also read a few essays from ‘Otherwise known as the Human Condition‘ from which I came across an essay on the photographer Jacques Henri Lartigue and this particular photograph of his:

Cap d’Antibes chez André Dubonnet (femme lisant The discovery of India) © Ministère de la Culture – France / A.A.J.H.L (Source)

For Dyer, the woman holding up Nehru’s tome is what sets the photograph apart:

The book is a touch of genius-the genius either of contrivance or of the moment-but, actually, if any element of the picture were removed (the wig, the glasses, the painted nails or lipstick) it would be thoroughly diminished. That’s the thing about all great photos, though. Everything in them is essential-even the inessential bits. It occurs to me that another important component of a photograph is the things that are not in it. The inclusion of certain things can not just diminish a photograph but destroy it. In this case-all the more remarkable in a photograph taken in 1953-the absence of a cigarette (so often considered an accessory of glamour) or ashtray is crucial to its allure and its contemporaneity. A cigarette would “date” or age the photograph as surely as it ages the faces of the people who smoke them. If there were any evidence of smoking I would have to look away. As it is, I can’t tear my eyes away. I can’t stop looking at her


Discover more from Manish Mohandas

Subscribe to get the latest posts sent to your email.

Leave a Reply